Best New Musical

2026

1. ★ Winner
   Paddington
2. Here We Are
3. Shucked
4. The Unlikely Pilgrimage of Harold Fry

2025

1. ★ Winner
   The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
2. MJ the Musical
3. Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812
4. Why Am I So Single?

2024

1. ★ Winner
   Operation Mincemeat
2. The Little Big Things
3. Next to Normal
4. A Strange Loop

2023

1. ★ Winner
   Standing at the Sky's Edge
2. The Band's Visit
3. Sylvia
4. Tammy Faye

2022

1. ★ Winner
   Back to the Future
2. Frozen
3. Get Up, Stand Up
4. Moulin Rouge!
5. The Drifters Girl

2020

1. ★ Winner
   Dear Evan Hansen
2. & Juliet
3. Amélie
4. Waitress

2019

1. ★ Winner
   Come from Away
2. Fun Home
3. Six
4. Tina

2018

1. ★ Winner
   Hamilton
2. An American in Paris
3. Everybody's Talking About Jamie
4. Girl from the North Country
5. Young Frankenstein

2017

1. ★ Winner
   Groundhog Day
2. Dreamgirls
3. The Girls
4. School of Rock

2016

1. ★ Winner
   Kinky Boots
2. Bend It Like Beckham
3. In the Heights
4. Mrs Henderson Presents

Compiled from each award's announced results and Wikipedia, with a source for every ceremony. Spotted a mistake? Please tell us.