Best Direction of a Musical

202679th edition

1. ★ Winner
   Zhailon Levingston & Bill Rauch

   Cats: The Jellicle Ball
2. Michael Arden

   The Lost Boys
3. Lear deBessonet

   Ragtime
4. Christopher Gattelli

   Schmigadoon!
5. Tim Jackson

   Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

202578th edition

1. ★ Winner
   Michael Arden

   Maybe Happy Ending
2. Saheem Ali

   Buena Vista Social Club
3. David Cromer

   Dead Outlaw
4. Christopher Gattelli

   Death Becomes Her
5. Jamie Lloyd

   Sunset Boulevard

202477th edition

1. ★ Winner
   Danya Taymor

   The Outsiders
2. Maria Friedman

   Merrily We Roll Along
3. Michael Greif

   Hell's Kitchen
4. Leigh Silverman

   Suffs
5. Jessica Stone

   Water for Elephants

202376th edition

1. ★ Winner
   Michael Arden

   Parade
2. Lear deBessonet

   Into the Woods
3. Casey Nicholaw

   Some Like It Hot
4. Jack O'Brien

   Shucked
5. Jessica Stone

   Kimberly Akimbo

202275th edition

1. ★ Winner
   Marianne Elliott

   Company
2. Jamie Armitage & Lucy Moss

   Six
3. Stephen Brackett

   A Strange Loop
4. Conor McPherson

   Girl from the North Country
5. Christopher Wheeldon

   MJ

202174th edition

1. ★ Winner
   Alex Timbers

   Moulin Rouge!
2. Phyllida Lloyd

   Tina
3. Diane Paulus

   Jagged Little Pill

201973rd edition

1. ★ Winner
   Rachel Chavkin

   Hadestown
2. Scott Ellis

   Tootsie
3. Daniel Fish

   Oklahoma!
4. Des McAnuff

   Ain't Too Proud
5. Casey Nicholaw

   The Prom

201872nd edition

1. ★ Winner
   David Cromer

   The Band's Visit
2. Michael Arden

   Once on This Island
3. Tina Landau

   SpongeBob SquarePants
4. Casey Nicholaw

   Mean Girls
5. Bartlett Sher

   My Fair Lady

201771st edition

1. ★ Winner
   Christopher Ashley

   Come from Away
2. Rachel Chavkin

   Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812
3. Michael Greif

   Dear Evan Hansen
4. Matthew Warchus

   Groundhog Day
5. Jerry Zaks

   Hello, Dolly!

201670th edition

1. ★ Winner
   Thomas Kail

   Hamilton
2. Michael Arden

   Spring Awakening
3. John Doyle

   The Color Purple
4. Scott Ellis

   She Loves Me
5. George C. Wolfe

   Shuffle Along

Compiled from each award's announced results and Wikipedia, with a source for every ceremony. Spotted a mistake? Please tell us.